Institut des cultures arabes et méditerranéennes  (ICAM)
  • ACCUEIL & AGENDA
  • GALERIE D’ART
    • ARTISTES
  • LIBRAIRIE
    • LIVRES
    • PRESSE ARABE -ARAB MEDIAS – الصحف العربية ‎
    • ACTUALITES
  • ESPACE CAFE
  • QUI SOMMES NOUS ?
    • L’ICAM
    • LE COMITÉ
    • NOS SOUTIENS
    • NOS ACTIVITÉS
    • ACCÈS ET HORAIRES
    • GOOGLE MAP
  • Cliquez pour ouvrir le champ de recherche Cliquez pour ouvrir le champ de recherche Rechercher
  • Menu Menu

Israel and Palestine: To Leap Forward, First Look Backward / Mohammad Tarbush

dans ACTUALITÉS/par ICAM

Updated: 2014-09-29T17:59  Huffingtonpost

Israeli and Palestinian delegations are meeting in Cairo to agree on an agenda for negotiating amongst other things, the opening of the crossings and the reconstruction of Gaza including its port and airport. Even in the unlikely scenario that swift agreement will be reached on these issues, that agreement would only be a Band-Aid to the Israeli and Palestinian body politic. Renewed violent conflict looms.

Well-wishers to both sides should encourage the parties to address the causes and not the symptoms of the long-standing conflict. A good start would be to look backward, not forward, and examine what went wrong and became the source of tension between Israelis and Palestinians.

An objective survey would show that the present conflict started a century ago, not by Palestinians traveling to Eastern Europe or elsewhere to pick fights with Jewish communities there, but by waves of Jewish immigrants flooding Palestine for a host of reasons: spiritual, economic, colonial, and safety. Those immigrants arrived in an already populated country with a distinct population that traced its roots to time immemorial, and that was becoming increasingly conscious of its own national identity.

Post-World War I, Palestine was a flourishing country with an economic growth rate and a per capita income that then surpassed those of Turkey or Egypt, and with burgeoning cities like Jerusalem, Jaffa, and Haifa that had cinemas, concert halls, tennis courts, and arguably some of the best schools in the Middle East.

The arrival of the new immigrants with their own nationalist fervor posed an existential threat to the indigenous population. Constructing Israel inevitably meant deconstructing Palestine. Realizing this, some Zionist pioneers, such as Moshe Menuhin, father of the violinist Yehudi, abandoned the idea and became forceful critics. Others, immersed in Zionist dogma, became leaders insensitive to Palestinian aspirations. They committed massacres and carried out the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians deemed necessary for reincarnating Zion.

Israel was thus created in 1948 on 55 percent of historic Palestine following a UN General Assembly non-binding recommendation. But less than a year later, Israel expanded its territory by another 23 percent. These operations resulted in 70 percent of the Palestinian people becoming refugees. The final 22 percent of the territory, namely the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, was occupied in 1967.

Since then, two generations of Palestinians have known only Israeli generals and colonels as governors and besiegers of their towns and villages and have been ruthlessly subjected to a long and harsh military occupation.

A Palestinian Christian or Muslim living in Bethlehem, for example, cannot go to pray at his respective church or mosque in Jerusalem five miles away without an elusive permit. Palestinian children attending schools in East Jerusalem are not allowed to study the Nakba, but are required to study the Holocaust.

Israel grants the right of return to any Jew from anywhere on the flimsy basis that his or her ancestors may have lived in ancient Palestine some 3,000 years ago, but denies that right to Palestinian Christians and Muslims who were forced out of Palestine in 1948 or 1967.

Palestinians are not allowed to import or export anything without rarely granted Israeli licenses. Such policies undercut Palestinian economic development and have turned both the West Bank and the Gaza Strip into dumping grounds for Israeli products.

By incessantly demeaning Palestinians or denying their very existence, Israeli leaders created a false reality. From their ivory tower, they look down at the Palestinian people and their national aspirations with a blurred vision and reckon that their rule over them can last ad infinitum.

 

While hundreds of civilians, particularly children, were being massacred in Gaza this summer, Israeli spokespersons repeatedly claimed that they had nothing against the Palestinian people. Palestinians scoffed at such nonsense.

Israel’s public discourse resulted in an upsurge of fanaticism amongst the settlers’ communities. Listening to some settlers justify their takeover of Palestinian land is surreal.

The prevailing status quo is untenable.

All signs indicate that even if the 20-year-old peace process were to succeed, it would at best be a 1919 Versailles-style agreement that would only pave the way for bloodier conflicts to come. Power-based treaties produce lulls in hostilities but not durable solutions to conflicts. For the latter, justice-based agreements are needed.

Israel should know by now that even cutting-edge arms and technology cannot break a people’s will to be free. It should also know that its imposed rule over another people has detrimental effects on its own society.

Ignoring these compelling realities and continuing with business as usual is sheer folly.

In my opinion, there are only two peaceful ways out of this morass:

The first is for a Palestinian state to be created on the pre-1967 borders and for Israel to accept the Palestinian refugees’ right of return to the 23 percent of territory it added to the 55 percent area allocated to it by the 1947 UN Partition Plan.

The second is to drop all dogma and accept the creation of a truly democratic, bi-national state where both Israelis and Palestinians can live as equals.

Either of these options should enable the two people to let bygones be bygones and work together as good neighbors, like the Germans and the French have learned to do or, as the federated Swiss actually do, notwithstanding their linguistic and religious diversity.

Partager :

  • Partager sur Facebook(ouvre dans une nouvelle fenêtre) Facebook
  • Partager sur X(ouvre dans une nouvelle fenêtre) X

Related

Partager cette publication
  • Partager sur Facebook
  • Partager sur X
  • Partager sur Pinterest
  • Partager sur LinkedIn
  • Partager sur Tumblr
  • Partager par Mail
https://www.icamge.ch/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/isr-pal.jpg 253 570 ICAM https://www.icamge.ch/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/olivier-icam-short-300x145.png ICAM2014-10-01 17:45:112014-10-01 17:45:11Israel and Palestine: To Leap Forward, First Look Backward / Mohammad Tarbush

Soutenir l’ICAM

Dans le site

Search Search

Presse arabe

Retrouvez les titres de la presse arabe

Retrouvez les titres de la presse arabe en lien

Fête de l’Olivier – Festival des musiques arabes et méditerranéennes

NOS ACTIVITES EN VIDEO

Nos activités en videos

Nos vidéos

ENSEIGNEMENT DE LA LANGUE ARABE POUR ENFANTS

Formation continue arabe

CASCI – Chambre de commerce Arabo-Suisse


  • Actualités
  • Rendez-vous annuels
  • Livres
  • Formations
    1. * Enseignement de l'arabe aux enfants (école publique)
      * Cours de langue arabe
      * Cours de danses arabes
      * Ateliers cuisines arabes
  • Nos soutiens
  • Presse arabe
    1. Retrouvez ici une sélection de journaux de langue arabe
  • Sites amis
    1. Associations actives Sites amis Journées de la science / Beyrouth Sites culturels
  • Nos bonnes adresses
  • ÉCRIVEZ-NOUS !
  • En poursuivant votre navigation sur ce site, vous acceptez le dépôt de cookies et technologies similaires.

    Cliquez sur le bouton "J’accepte" pour consentir à ces utilisations.
    Politique relative aux cookies

    Sites amis

    L'Orient Littéraire
    CERMAM
    Association Linkchild
    Diverscités
    Ateliers d'ethnomusicologie
    Qantara-Méditerranée
    Inst.for Palestine Studies
    Club 44
    Artistes suisses solidaires avec Gaza
    Blog Planète photos
    Artlink
    l''amour du son
    Pages du Liban
    Plateforme interreligieuse de Genève
    Challenge To Change
    Les clefs du Moyen-Orient

    INFOS PRATIQUES

    Accès et horaires

    Contact

    Inscription à la newsletter



    Nos soutiens

    Soutenir l'ICAM

    Agenda

    Tout l'agenda
    Conférences
    Littérature
    Musique
    Expositions
    Art culinaire
    Archives

    ICAM

    Galerie d'art
    Librairie
    Espace café
    Revue de presse

    LIENS UTILES

    Genève coopération internationale
    Genève solidarité internationale
    Bureau de l'intégration
    Traducteurs assermentés

    ‎

    Marque-pages

      © Copyright - Institut des cultures arabes et méditerranéennes (ICAM)
      • ACCUEIL & AGENDA
      • GALERIE D’ART
      • LIBRAIRIE
      • ESPACE CAFE
      • QUI SOMMES NOUS ?
      Lien vers: Les producteurs de cinéma Dashishah et Kawadri font revenir Michael Caton-Jones à Londres Lien vers: Les producteurs de cinéma Dashishah et Kawadri font revenir Michael Caton-Jones à Londres Les producteurs de cinéma Dashishah et Kawadri font revenir Michael Caton-Jones... Lien vers: Deux films tunisiens récompensés au Festival du Film Arabe de Malmö Lien vers: Deux films tunisiens récompensés au Festival du Film Arabe de Malmö Deux films tunisiens récompensés au Festival du Film Arabe de Malmö
      Faire défiler vers le haut Faire défiler vers le haut Faire défiler vers le haut